New research published in the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin provides evidence that changing how people view their past struggles with depression can improve their ability to achieve life goals. The study suggests that reframing depression as a sign of strength, rather than weakness, boosts self-confidence and tangible goal progress. This psychological shift helped participants make nearly 50 percent more progress on their personal objectives over a two-week period compared to those who did not receive the intervention.
Depression is a widespread mental health condition that often hinders a person’s ability to pursue their ambitions, such as career advancement, hobbies, or maintaining relationships. While the biological symptoms of the illness, such as fatigue and lack of motivation, certainly play a major role, the researchers suspected another social factor was at play.
Society often stigmatizes depression, promoting a narrative that paints those who suffer from it as inherently weak or damaged. The scientists hypothesized that this societal label of “weakness” becomes internalized by individuals. This acts as a mental barrier even when they are not currently experiencing severe symptoms.
“Before our study, it was not clear why people who have experienced depression can experience goal pursuit problems even after their depressive symptoms have faded,” said study author Christina A. Bauer of the University of Vienna.
The researchers reasoned that if people believe they are fundamentally flawed because of their depression, they may lack the confidence to strive for their goals. This creates a self-fulfilling prophecy where the fear of weakness leads to actual struggles in achievement. The team wanted to test if flipping this narrative could restore confidence. They aimed to show that the struggle against depression is actually proof of resilience, perseverance, and emotional intelligence.
To test this theory, the researchers conducted three separate experiments involving a total of 748 participants. All participants were adults who had previously been prescribed anti-depressants, indicating they had experienced depression at a clinical level.
In the first experiment, the researchers recruited 158 participants and randomly assigned them to one of two groups. The control group engaged in an active control task where they read factual information about depression from the American Psychiatric Association and reflected on their own experiences. This ensured that any differences found were not simply due to thinking about depression. The second group participated in the “depression-reframing” intervention.
The depression-reframing exercise was a brief session lasting about twenty minutes. Participants read stories from others who described how dealing with depression required strength. These stories highlighted qualities like perseverance and the ability to manage difficult emotions. After reading these examples, participants were asked to write a reflection on how their own battle with depression demonstrated their personal strength. They were also asked to frame this as advice to help others, which is a technique often used to reinforce new ways of thinking.
The results of the first experiment showed that those who completed the reframing exercise reported higher levels of general self-efficacy. In psychology, self-efficacy is a person’s belief in their ability to succeed in specific situations or accomplish a task. Essentially, the participants who viewed their depression as a source of strength felt more capable of handling life’s challenges compared to those in the control group.
The second experiment involved a larger group of 419 participants. This study aimed to replicate the initial findings and see if the boosted confidence applied to specific, real-world goals. After completing the same reframing or control exercises as in the first study, participants identified a specific personal goal they wanted to achieve in the next two weeks. These goals varied widely, ranging from physical self-care, like exercising three times a week, to work-related tasks, like finishing an assignment.
The researchers found that the reframing exercise not only increased general confidence but also boosted commitment to these specific personal goals. To understand why this happened, the researchers analyzed the data further. They found that the exercise changed how participants viewed the compatibility between their illness and their success.
In the control group, 71 percent of participants felt that the strengths needed to achieve their goals did not describe people with depression. In the reframing group, this figure dropped significantly to 52 percent. By seeing depression as compatible with being strong, participants felt more empowered to pursue their objectives.
The final experiment was a longitudinal study, meaning the researchers tracked participants over time to measure actual progress. They recruited 171 individuals who had experienced depression. As in the previous rounds, participants completed either the reframing exercise or the control activity and set a specific goal. The researchers then contacted the participants two weeks later to assess their progress.
The difference between the two groups was substantial. Participants in the control group reported that they had completed about 43 percent of their goal after two weeks. In contrast, those who underwent the depression-reframing exercise reported reaching 64 percent completion. This represents a 49 percent increase in goal progress driven by the brief psychological intervention.
“The size of the reframing-intervention acknowledging strengths of people with depression was as big as moving people from a heavy to a moderate depression,” Bauer told PsyPost. “This highlights the severity of stigma effects of depression – in addition to the effects of depression as a mental disease.”
Additionally, the third experiment explored how participants might handle a relapse. Participants were asked to imagine they were experiencing severe depressive symptoms again. Those who had completed the reframing exercise indicated they would treat themselves with more compassion and respect in such a scenario compared to the control group. This suggests that the intervention might help build resilience against future episodes of illness.
“We show that in addition to the symptoms of depression (e.g., fatigue based on hormonal imbalances), stigmatizing narratives about depression – the idea that people who have experienced depression are weak people – can undermine successful goal pursuit, too,” Bauer explained. “Even when depression is over, people can, based on stigmatizing societal narratives, still think they are weak people, which can undermine their confidence in themselves, and make goal pursuit more difficult.”
“The solution we tested: better acknowledging one’s strength in the face of depression can help. When you or your loved ones experience depression, don’t overlook the strength it often takes to deal with depression – to fight the urge to stay in bed all day, and to continue living one’s life despite all the obstacles depression brings with it. This ‘reframing of depression’ we developed can help people better see their strength and pursue their goals in lifes, as we show.”
While these findings offer a promising avenue for supporting people with depression, there are limitations to consider. The study relied on self-reported measures of goal progress rather than objective observations. It is possible that participants in the intervention group simply felt more optimistic about their progress, though self-reports generally correlate well with actual behavior in psychological research. Future research could benefit from using objective data, such as fitness tracker logs or workplace performance records, to verify these improvements.
Another limitation involves the duration of the effect. The study tracked participants for only two weeks. It remains unclear how long the boost in confidence and goal pursuit lasts without a “booster” session to reinforce the message. The researchers also note that the participants were recruited from online platforms and were mostly from Western countries. It is not yet known if this specific type of reframing would work as effectively in different cultural contexts where the concept of the self and individual achievement might be viewed differently.
The researchers emphasize that this intervention is not a replacement for traditional treatments like therapy or medication. “Of course, treating depression as a disease itself (e.g., through psychotherapy, or medication) remains key,” Bauer noted. “Our intervention approach addressing stigma complements, but does in no way replace these approaches.”
Future research plans to explore if this “strength-based” approach could apply to other stigmatized groups, Bauer said. The researchers suggest that individuals who have survived trauma or who live with chronic physical illnesses might also benefit from reframing their struggles as evidence of their resilience. Recognizing the hidden strength in these experiences could offer a scalable, low-cost way to support mental well-being and personal growth across a variety of populations.
The study, “Depression-Reframing: Recognizing the Strength in Mental Illness Improves Goal Pursuit Among People Who Have Faced Depression,” was authored by Christina A. Bauer, Gregory M. Walton, Jürgen Hoyer, and Veronika Job.
Leave a comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.